COLLEGE STUDENTS STRUGGLE THROUGH UNUSUAL LEARNING AND LIVING EXPERIENCE

Mary Kreitz • March 16, 2021

For many students attending college during 2020 and 2021, the college experience hasn’t been at all what they were expecting. Many colleges and universities shut down in the spring of 2020 as a response to the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. Although most have since re-opened with heavy reliance on online learning and social distancing, everyone would agree that attending college is not the same as it was in past years.

A DIFFERENT EDUCATIONAL EXPEREIENCE

Online learning is very different from attending class in person. Many college students find themselves disappointed with the quality of the academic instruction they receive via online lectures. Some students report that they have very little direct instruction from professors, relying instead on reading material, pre-recorded lectures and written assignments. While this may work for some learners, others find it much harder to understand and retain the information. One college student commented, “I’m not learning nearly as much as I would have if classes were held in person.” Common complaints include that the only way to ask a question is to email a professor and hope to receive a response, that recorded lectures and printed texts pale in comparison to the rich communication that comes from live face-to-face interaction, and that online content, often prepared by professors who were never trained to work in this format, is boring. So called “Zoom Fatigue” is a real problem. It can be mentally draining to be focused on computer screens for extended periods of time. A college student who was interviewed for this article stated, “There’s a reason I didn’t apply to an online university. I wanted to take classes on campus.”


Some subjects just don’t translate easily into online experiences. Labs and other performance-based courses require a more hands-on, in person format. As a compromise, some colleges and universities have offered in-person classes with limited class size, schedules that are a hybrid of in-person and online instruction or courses that have been condensed to run for fewer weeks. Again, these formats may work for some students, but many others struggle with them.

THE RESOURCE GAP

COVID-19 has highlighted inequity in access to the types of resources that make a huge difference in a student’s ability to successfully engage in remote learning. Do you have access to a reliable, high-speed internet connection? Do you have the software to run the programs you need? Do you have a quiet space to be able to attend online classes or focus on online assignments without interruptions? Whether you have access to a high-end computer, or a more basic model can make a big difference in the quality of your academic experience.

LIVING ARRANGEMENTS

When universities shut down, many students who were living in on-campus housing lost their place to stay with short notice to make other arrangements. Some were able to move back home with family. Others did not have a safe or supportive home to move back to. Those who moved back home may have found themselves facing increased responsibility to care for siblings or sick relatives. Many had to take on more responsibility for contributing financially to the household, especially if parents or other family members lost employment, had their hours cut or were unable to work due to illness or a physical condition. One student who chose to stay in her dorm reported that so many others left or never moved in, that she found herself living in an eerily empty building which served as a constant reminder of how alone she was.  That leads us to the next topic . . .

SOCIAL ISOLATION

One of the most common concerns among college students, and many other groups throughout the country, is the sense of disconnection from others. For many students, college is a time to meet new people from a variety of backgrounds and to make connections that could help them move on to the next phase of their life. Even the brief interactions that occur as students find their seats in lecture halls or pass each other on campus can be the start of life-long friendships.

Those types of interactions don’t happen as easily in virtual classrooms or when wearing masks and maintaining safe social distances.


In addition to isolation from peers and social acquaintances, the pandemic has also resulted in a reduction of interactions that foster professional development. There have been less chances to get involved with mentors and with the types of role models who can provide academic and professional support. Internship and summer job opportunities are not as readily available as they have been in the past and the quality of those experiences is not what it used to be.

Many people struggle with mental health problems during their college years. Trying to juggle school, work, extracurricular activities, friends and family while also trying to figure out the direction of the rest of your life is an enormous challenge – and it has gotten worse over the past year .A 2018-2019 survey of college students found that approximately 18.4% reported experiencing depression and 23.6% reported experiencing anxiety.

Over the past year, the National Institute of Health Statistics (NIHS) partnered with the Census Bureau to conduct Household Pulse Surveys to capture an impression of the impact of COVID-19 in the US. According to their results, rates of depression have risen to more than 43% and anxiety to more than 51% of persons ages 18-29 years old.

WHAT CAN YOU DO?

Give yourself credit for what you are doing. This is not a normal year. If you are feeling unsettled, stressed and overwhelmed, it isn’t just you. Things really are harder this year. Take a moment to list and recognize all that you actually do in a typical day. Give yourself credit for doing as well as you are under difficult circumstances.


Set realistic expectations. Perfection is not a realistic goal. Mistakes will happen. Look at mistakes as opportunities to learn, rather than as evidence that you are a failure. Keep in mind that taking on too much at once just means that you’re doing more things less well.

Communicate. Whether it seems like it or not, professors want students to succeed. If you are struggling with your academic work or something is getting in the way of your ability to meet deadlines, communicate with your professors about it. Let them know what’s going on. Ask for an extension. Ask for the resources you need. Talk with your friends and family. Let them know how much they matter to you, even if you aren’t as available as you have been in the past. Let them know what you need from them. People often do want to help. They may not know that you need help, and they may not know the best way to help, so you must guide them. If you’re worried about being a burden, think about how willing you would be to help if it was one of your friends reaching out to you.


Don’t be ashamed to reach out for professional help. If you are struggling, know that you don’t have to go through it alone. Help is available. There is no shame in seeking professional help. It doesn’t mean you’ve failed. It doesn’t mean you’re broken. It means you’re human and you’re going through a lot. Help is available. Most colleges and universities have on campus counseling services for students who need them. Both college- and community-based services are available in person or through telehealth. If you or someone you know is in distress, you can call the National Suicide Lifeline at 1-800-273-8255, or text “HELP” to 741-741.


Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health's Trauma Program Manager Mary Kreitz, LPC, CDCA, is the author of this blog post. Mary is an expert in her field with 18 years of experience. If your child is struggling because of receiving microaggressions, please contact C&A at 330-433-6075.

RECENT POSTS

By Mary M. Kreitz November 21, 2024
For many people changes in the seasons also bring changes in mood, energy, sleep, weight and appetite. Some researchers have found that as many as 90% of people report noticing these types of changes in themselves. However, for some people, the changes are so intense that they interfere with the person’s ability to function in their daily life.  Seasonal Affective Disorder or SAD is a type of clinical depression that occurs with a consistent seasonal pattern. The symptoms of SAD are the same as those for other depressive disorders; what is different is that the symptoms begin every year around the same time, last for several months, and then go away for the rest of the year. The most common form of SAD is what is known as winter-pattern SAD in which depressive symptoms start in the fall or early winter and end in the spring. Another less common form is known as summer-pattern SAD and is associated with depressive symptoms that occur during the spring and summer months and improve in the fall.
By Mary M. Kreitz November 6, 2024
The 2024 election has brought a lot of fear and stress into the lives of people throughout the country. A recent survey by the American Psychological Association found that 77% of adults in the US are worried about the future of the nation, 73% reported feeling stressed out about the economy and 69% reported feeling stressed about the presidential election. When adults are feeling this high of a level of stress, you can bet that children and adolescents are feeling it too.
By Daniel Mucci October 1, 2024
Are you a trusted adult to your child or someone’s child in your life? What are the characteristics of a trusted adult?  Trusted adults are viewed by children or adolescents as a safe figure that listens without judgment, agenda or expectation, but with the sole purpose of supporting and encouraging positivity within a young person’s life. Today’s youth identify a trusted adult as someone who is willing to listen and engage, rather than lecture and give orders. Young adults are interested in having open conversations about mental health, social media, bullying and sharing their own experiences.
By Daniel Mucci September 9, 2024
Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health’s (C&A) The Canton Repository Let Your Light Shine presented by the Massillon Eagles FOE #190 is Sept. 21 at the DoubleTree by Hilton, Canton, from 6-9 p.m. The 19th annual event supports the youth mental health programs and services C&A provides each year to our 4,100 clients.
By Mary M. Kreitz June 18, 2024
You have probably heard the scary statistics. LGBTQ+ youth are at higher risk for serious mental health problems (such as anxiety and depression) than their non-LGBTQ+ peers. They’re more likely to consider suicide, more likely to attempt suicide and more likely to engage in non-suicidal self-harm.
By Dr. Robert Willoughby June 4, 2024
Hope and hopelessness play a large role in the phenomenon of suicide and depression including that of children and adolescents (Liu, et al., 2021). On the positive side I am always reminded of the use of hope to overcome hopelessness in stories reminiscent of a hero’s journey. Stories, where in the face of insurmountable odds, one digs in deep to find themselves, their own hope, and the hope of others joining together to help whilst overcoming trials and tribulations (Campbell, 2011).
By Dan Mucci May 16, 2024
Suicidal ideation is on the rise nationwide, especially among teenagers and college-age students. Post COVID, adolescents are struggling to handle a variety of situations and have limited coping skills to help them through the challenges. One of the biggest challenges is loneliness.
By Dan Mucci April 16, 2024
The sixth annual Stark County Schools Mental Health Awareness Week is May 6-10 Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health (C&A), CommQuest Services and Pathway Caring for Children will partner to bring positive mental health awareness to more than 53,000 students and 7,000 support and administrative staff in all 18 Stark County School districts.
By Chris Alpert November 16, 2023
In the film, I’m Not Racist… Am I? as introduced and explored in first of this three-part blog post series, the participants engaged in multiple workshops that address race and racism. Interpersonally, the group of students grapple with their own differences and similarities, which impact the content and emotions they share with each other. There are several moments in the film that demonstrate the clear differences in the participants’ understanding of race. In the first workshop, the students were exposed to the idea that all white people are inherently racist seeing as American society was founded on principles meant to support white people (see more on structural racism here, here, and here for further understanding). Several white students in the film became emotional during that workshop. Most students remained quiet. Following this workshop, a black student and a white student were filmed independently of each other in their own homes and discussed the workshop and what they learned with their families. The white student discussed the differences between structural racism and bigotry with her mother and struggled to identify with the principles taught in the training. The black student stated to his mother how almost everything spoken in that workshop applied to him. The student further discussed his feelings by stating how overt racism is and yet how “subliminal” it is at the same time. How can something be so in your face and yet under your feet simultaneously? I immediately reflected on the dialectic of something being so clear and yet so vague. The film continued to grapple with student differences. At the beginning of the film, one white male student discussed with his mother how he feels that all individuals, if they apply themselves wholeheartedly, have the same chance of success regardless of their skin, gender, sexuality or other demographic factors. As a white man myself, I must confess that when I was in high school, I had the same mindset. How could it be different? Especially when I was reading mythic bootstrap literature in high school classes. Sure, the harder you work the more you deserve, but that statement does not work for all Americans. I had not accounted for racial factors that inhibit the growth of others, not to mention socio-economic factors, nationalities, citizenship status, gender and age. I continued to reflect on these statements and connected them to my experience in high school in New York City. In the wake of the Black Lives Matter movement responding to the murder of George Floyd, multiple private progressive schools in New York, including the one I went to, suffered scrutiny from students and alumni who identify as black, indigenous people of color (BIPOC). Multiple Instagram accounts surfaced with the handle “BLACK AT [school name].” I read the posts in 2020, and again before writing this post, and remembered feeling horrified knowing these acts of racism, bigotry and microaggressions happened all around me. This was subliminal to me, yet overt to others.
More Posts
Share by: